Home
blog
About
Speaking Engagements
Contact
Resources

Mr. IP Law

Home
blog
About
Speaking Engagements
Contact
Resources
April 18, 2022
John Russell
The Illusion of Quality at the USPTO

The Illusion of Quality at the USPTO - its clear from the USPTO’s very own explanation of the program.

The Illusion of Quality at the USPTO
March 21, 2019
John Russell
New Informative PTAB Decision on 101

A new informative decision on 101 from the PTAB (with a dissent).

New Informative PTAB Decision on 101
January 28, 2019
John Russell
System Diagnostics and Section 101

The PTAB confirms in a Honda appeal that system diagnostic inventions do not need to perform an action in response to the diagnostic determination to be patent eligible.

System Diagnostics and Section 101
November 28, 2018
John Russell
Amicus Brief Regarding Prosecution Re-opening ...

Read the brief here!

Amicus Brief Regarding Prosecution Re-opening at the Federal Circuit
July 16, 2018
John Russell
PLEA FOR YOUR HELP

The USPTO is Breaking the Law - Read how and lend your support to the cause.

PLEA FOR YOUR HELP
John Russell
April 15, 2024

Interplay between Obvious to Try and Routine Optimization

John Russell
April 15, 2024
Interplay between Obvious to Try and Routine Optimization

When examiners improperly mix together different rationales into a single rejection, be ready to call it out and address each one separately to illustrate errors. Read about a recent case from Under Armor related to a footwear innovation and how the PTAB decided the issue.

Comment
John Russell
March 26, 2024

Using Provisional Filing Dates Offensively - It's Not Automatic

John Russell
March 26, 2024
Using Provisional Filing Dates Offensively - It's Not Automatic

Some examiner skirt the requirements of establishing continuity of disclosure when relying on a US provisional filing date. Read here how to push back.

Comment
John Russell
March 18, 2024

Claim interplay under the Broadest Reasonable Interpretation (BRI)

John Russell
March 18, 2024
Claim interplay under the Broadest Reasonable Interpretation (BRI)

Remember that when arguing about the proper scope of a claim term, it is important to consider the use of the disputed limitation in other claims.

Comment
John Russell
March 4, 2024

The Attraction of Simplicity in Hindsight

John Russell
March 4, 2024
The Attraction of Simplicity in Hindsight

Viewing things in hindsight can be irresistible to one’s human nature. Read about a case where the simplicity of an invention when viewed in hindsight was overcome at the PTAB with declaration evidence explaining the context of the invention.

Comment
John Russell
February 26, 2024

Where Does It End?

John Russell
February 26, 2024
Where Does It End?

A head-scratcher of a case comes down from the PTAB as to Section 101. Read about how a technical improvement that reduces memory requirements for a battery monitoring system is nevertheless deemed too abstract because the improvement memory allegedly merely benefited abstract math.

Comment
John Russell
February 19, 2024

Are Smartphone Apps Protectable With Utility Patents?

John Russell
February 19, 2024
Are Smartphone Apps Protectable With Utility Patents?

An example PTAB appeal illustrates the substantial hurdles to those trying to protect novel and inventive smartphone apps.

Comment
John Russell
February 16, 2024

But That's Not In Your Claim

John Russell
February 16, 2024
But That's Not In Your Claim

This post explains and illustrates a common USPTO practice of side-stepping your arguments with a red herring response.

Comment
John Russell
January 10, 2024

All Functional Language Is Not Necessarily Created Equal

John Russell
January 10, 2024
All Functional Language Is Not Necessarily Created Equal

Be aware that some PTAB judges can interpret “configured to” claim elements more broadly (and thus more easily rejected in view of prior art) than “adapted to” claim elements.

Comment
John Russell
January 8, 2024

Improper Hindsight In Generalizing the Teachings of the Prior Art

John Russell
January 8, 2024
Improper Hindsight In Generalizing the Teachings of the Prior Art

Read about improper hindsight, and different ways it can show up in obviousness rejections.

Comment
John Russell
January 3, 2024

Obviousness - Merely Being Conventional Is Not Motivation

John Russell
January 3, 2024
Obviousness - Merely Being Conventional Is Not Motivation

Whether or not claimed features are conventional, that does not, by itself, constitute a reason to combine them. Read the latest post that discuses a common flaw in obviousness rejections - improper motivation to combine.

Comment
John Russell
December 18, 2023

Enhancing Processing Efficiency of the Computer Itself, or Just a Mere Tool

John Russell
December 18, 2023
Enhancing Processing Efficiency of the Computer Itself, or Just a Mere Tool

This posts illustrates the challenges in overcoming 101 rejections at the USPTO by relying on the improvement of processing efficiency of the computer itself. Don’t fall into the trap of the computer being a mere tool when trying to secure protection for a software-related invention.

1 Comment
John Russell
December 12, 2023

Core Wireless and Example 37 Help Roche Secure a 101 Win

John Russell
December 12, 2023
Core Wireless and Example 37 Help Roche Secure a 101 Win

Read about a recent PTAB case where the particular presentation of data on a user interface is found patent eligible with help from Core Wireless and Example 37 of the USPTO Guidelines.

Comment
John Russell
December 4, 2023

Legal Precedent to Support the Prima Facia Case

John Russell
December 4, 2023
Legal Precedent to Support the Prima Facia Case

Read about a recent PTAB case illustrating how evidence can make or break the case when the examiner uses “legal precedent” as the basis for a rejection.

Comment
John Russell
November 27, 2023

Coatings, Layers, and Substrates - Different Yet The Same At The PTAB

John Russell
November 27, 2023
Coatings, Layers, and Substrates - Different Yet The Same At The PTAB

Be careful if you work in technologies that utilize layers, coatings, and/or substrates. See how these terms can lead to unintended interpretations where any one of them can mean any of the others.

Comment
John Russell
November 15, 2023

The End of Dynamic Drinkware at the USPTO

John Russell
November 15, 2023
The End of Dynamic Drinkware at the USPTO

Read the latest update about a precedential decision from the USPTO that affects the offensive use of US provisional applications.

Comment
John Russell
November 7, 2023

Crafting Effective Arguments Against an Examiner's Interpretation of a Claim Term: A Guide for Patent Professionals

John Russell
November 7, 2023
Crafting Effective Arguments Against an Examiner's Interpretation of a Claim Term: A Guide for Patent Professionals

The battle over claim term interpretation is a common challenge in patent prosecution. Read about a recent case at the PTAB and see the various ways that patent professionals can better combat an improper interpretation by an examiner.

Comment
John Russell
October 31, 2023

What Separates A Good Patent Application From A Great Patent Application

John Russell
October 31, 2023
What Separates A Good Patent Application From A Great Patent Application

Patent Drafting Tip - Even if it may seem verbose to explicitly describe detailed examples illustrating the inventive approach that seem obvious from the disclosure, failing to do so can severely limit amendment options when they are needed most during prosecution.

1 Comment
John Russell
October 24, 2023

Robust Software Applications and The Role of Technical Problem and Solution Disclosures

John Russell
October 24, 2023
Robust Software Applications and The Role of Technical Problem and Solution Disclosures

Read about how the problem-solution approach can enhance your software patent application, and see how the lack of such a strategy can lead to trouble at the PTAB.

Comment
John Russell
October 16, 2023

Claim Interpretation and Implicit Definitions in the Specification

John Russell
October 16, 2023
Claim Interpretation and Implicit Definitions in the Specification

Read about a recent PTAB case involving a baseball bat invention. The PTAB used the applicant’s specification to find an implicit definition of a claim term so as to reject the examiner’s overly broad interpretation.

Comment
John Russell
October 10, 2023

Restrictions and Non-Compliant Responses

John Russell
October 10, 2023
Restrictions and Non-Compliant Responses

Read the latest post about how to hunker down and push back against improper restrictions meant to tie your hands throughout prosecution.

Comment
Newer Posts
Older Posts
Back to Top
McCoy Russell LLP, 1410 NW Johnson St., Portland, OR, 97209, United Statesinfo@mccrus.com